Synopsis/blurb…..
Introducing a new
character and a new novel from one of the most prominent Irish crime writers of
the last two decades. For fans of Ken Bruen's Jack Taylor and Inspector Brant
series, L.A. Confidential by James Ellroy, and Mystic River by Dennis Lehane,
comes a noir crime story set in New York City.
A rogue ex-cop from
the Irish Garda manipulates a transfer to work for the NYPD in an exchange
program. However, it turns out that the cop is really a serial killer wanted for
murder in Ireland, and now, New York City.
(Note regarding blurb
– unless the book was drastically revised post-ARC release – or I paid
absolutely no attention to it whatsoever when reading – the second paragraph
above is total baloney.)
Slightly more enjoyable than the last book I read from the
author, (only just) but still far less than his best, though in truth the
author was also let down here by the formatting of the book. My read was a
digital ARC from Edelweiss review site and the divisions between breaks in the
narrative and chapters etc was fairly dire which added to a bit of reader
confusion.
We have another short-ish book at about 220 pages long. We
have a disgraced Garda – Tommy Ryan rocking up in New York and crossing paths
with another ex-cop, Merrick. Merrick runs a bar and in the past was
investigating a child serial killer alongside PI Moe Prager. (A killer of
children, as opposed to a child who kills.) Prager now lies in a coma.
BTW - Moe Prager is a character creation of Reed Farrell Coleman
- an author that Bruen has previously collaborated with to produce Tower. I
have a few of the Coleman-Prager books that I haven’t yet read, so can’t
speculate whether our man Merrick is one of Coleman’s characters that Bruen has
hijacked and adopted for his own use here, or is entirely a figment of his own
imagination.
As is the norm for the author he references and hat-tips a
fair few authors and books during the course of his narratives – Harry Crews, Nick
Tosches, Reed Farrel Coleman (obviously), Jim Fusilli, S.J. (Rozan?)
Anyway Ryan and Merrick meet in his bar and both sense a
kindred spirit and do a bit of male bonding….drinking, baseball, hurling, more
drinking and the odd bout of fisticuffs and sulking with each other.
Merrick can’t let the old case go and shows Ryan some notes
that the killer sent to him boasting about his kills and what he did to who and
how much he enjoyed it. Ryan signs on to help Merrick take down our killer.
Along the way we have a bit of love interest for Ryan with a
Native American lady, who he meets after be-friending her brother – a
construction worker in a bar. To earn cash to live, Ryan does a bit of
construction work and signs on with the Indian crew.
Might just be me getting
picky again, but if you ask me what springs to mind if you say CONSTRUCTION.
NEW YORK. NATIVE AMERICAN – I’d immediately think WORKING AT HEIGHT,
SKYSCRAPERS, NO SAFETY RIGS – BOOM 3 out of 3!
What do we reckon then - ethnic diversity embraced and
cherished in our fiction, or another stereotype trotted out?
Back to case – our intrepid duo have a couple of suspects
who fit the profile. We interview them, which ups the ante. Ryan’s spider-sense
feels that the culprit isn’t acting alone and that there is another player –
possibly a cop involved. Cue mayhem and a bloody and brutal resolution. Oh, and
we have some Russian mobsters, thrown in for good measure. (Another box ticked
on the global diversity box.)
Sad to say, I think I’m just jaded with this author now. Where he once
came across as dark and fresh and original, I just find him repeating tricks
from previous years. Unless of course he’s parodying himself.
Another example – exaggeration in the Irish dialect – FOOKIN
HELL, FOOKIN THIS, FOOKIN THAT – if Mr Bruen uses fookin once more, I think
I’ll take my fookin eyeball out with a fookin sharp needle, fookin pronto.
Plenty of action, dialogue, cultural references, overall not
the worst book ever, but far from great.
A generous 3 from 5.
Accessed via Edelweiss.
Interesting point, Col about the whole cultural stereotype thing. I know exactly what you mean, and I notice those things, too, when I see them. Same thing with dialect. Still, I'm glad you found some things to like about this one.
ReplyDeleteMargot - maybe reading it at a different time and in a different mood so much of it might not have irritated me.....but then again, I think I'm partly disappointed because he has proven himself capable of so much better in the past. It seemed a tired effort.
DeleteSince I have several of Bruen's books from the Brant and Jack Taylor and those will keep me busy for a while, I won't be worrying about any other of his books. Maybe someday I will try this, maybe not. The formatting in an ARC is unfortunate. I had that problem with one and I hope it did not influence my really poor reaction to the book.
ReplyDeleteI wouldn't recommend this to anyone to be truthful. It's just not that good. I had a similar issue with the formatting in a Bukowski I read as well, but eventually I managed to ignore it!
DeleteIt's good to see that Bruen is at least moving into new territory. Even so, as you know, I recently had a similar reaction to his novel Calibre: sort of been there, done that, recognize that trick . . . Of course, this may simply be my reaction to the idiosyncracy of his writing style.
ReplyDeleteI won't be rushing to acquire any more of his new stuff, John though I will get back to the unread Jack Taylor's at some point. Style over substance with his last few I think.
DeleteCol, I'm kind of pulled in by the plot and the character of an ex-Irish cop in New York in the backdrop of a serial crime. I haven't read Irish noir.
ReplyDeleteIt might be worthwhile trying this if you are approaching it with fresh eyes. Maybe I'm being uber-harsh because he has proven himself capable of so much better in the past.
DeleteI think this book had a quality alert placed on it at Amazon so nobody could buy it. I didn't plan to read this since I'd heard it wasn't all that good. My plan is to just stick to his series stuff which is far superior to his other stuff from the sounds of what I'm reading here. It's unfortunate that you picked up this one to read.
ReplyDeleteKeishon, I think you're right. I did look on Amazon before reviewing to get a feel for what other people thought. The reviews have stayed, but the book has gone from the dot.com site. In the UK, some chancer has a secondhand paperback for a grand, but Amazon aren't selling it and the kindle version. has disappeared. The only time I've heard of a book being pulled before was one where the author got outed for plagiarism. If Amazon withdraw all the bad books they're selling, half the store would be gone at least. How strange.
DeleteOh well, Taylor still waits for me!