Friday 29 July 2016



When a two-year-old girl is reported missing, DCI Andy Gilchrist is assigned the case. But Gilchrist soon suspects that the child's mother - Andrea Davis - may be responsible for her daughter's disappearance, or worse, her murder.

The case becomes politically sensitive when Gilchrist learns that Andrea is the daughter of Dougal Davis, a former MSP who was forced to resign from Scottish Parliament after being accused of physically abusing his third wife. Now a powerful businessman, Davis demands Gilchrist's removal from the case when his investigation seems to be stalling. But then the case turns on its head when Gilchrist learns that a paedophile, recently released from prison, now lives in the same area as the missing child. The paedophile is interrogated but hours later his body is found on the beach with evidence of blunt force trauma to the head, and Gilchrist launches a murder investigation.

As pressure relentlessly mounts on Gilchrist, he begins to unravel a dark family secret, a secret he believes will solve the fate of the missing child.

Praise for T.F. Muir:

'Rebus did it for Edinburgh. Laidlaw did it for Glasgow. Gilchrist might just be the bloke to put St Andrews on the crime fiction map.' Daily Record

'A bright new recruit to the swelling army of Scots crime writers.' Quintin Jardine

'Gripping and grisly, with plenty of twists and turns that race along with black humour.' Craig Robertson

'Gilchrist is intriguing, bleak and vulnerable... if I were living in St Andrews I'd sleep with the lights on.' Anna Smith

Read a couple of months ago in May and albeit against limited competition numbers-wise was May’s pick of the month.

This was my first time with Scottish author Frank Muir and his series character Detective Andy Gilchrist.

Gilchrist is pitched into a difficult case with the disappearance of a two year old girl. Things are further complicated by the fact she is the granddaughter of a former Scottish MSP. A quick resolution appears close at hand when it comes to light that a convicted paedophile has recently moved back to the area. This line of enquiry draws a blank – more so when the suspect is himself found dead.

An interesting police procedural – my first in a while – enhanced by some of the dynamics. Tensions almost leading to violence between Gilchrist and a fellow officer, an on-off relationship with one of the forensic officers, pressure from the hierarchy for a quick close on the case and the recovery of the missing girl, the high profile nature of the case – the press all over it like a rash, with our disgraced ex-MSP fuelling the fire.      

Gilchrist has other issues to contend with, in conjunction with the case, namely his love life and the impact it has on his grown-up children, especially his son Jack. Things aren’t too great between the pair of them, his son has used drugs in the past and now appears flush with money. Gilchrist suspects dealing as opposed to a run of luck and some success in his career as an artist. Mistrust and suspicion is mutual, especially when Jack is suspected of sex with a minor.

Back on the job, the difficulties thrust in his way by the fractured factions of the dysfunctional Davis family and the secrets they closely guard make life and the safe recovery of the young child further away than ever. Gilchrist needs to penetrate and unravel …. allegations of abuse, broken marriages, estrangements, mysterious Eastern European connections, smarmy well-heeled lawyers, mental illness, a dead husband and more.
5 from 5

This is the 6th book in the DI Andy Gilchrist series that T.F. Muir (T. Frank in the US) has penned. 
If money and time were limitless I'd happily read the earlier 5!

The author’s website is here
Catch him on Twitter - @FrankMuirAuthor

Thanks to Helen at publishers Little Brown for the review copy. Sorry for the delay!



  1. Sounds like a good read, Col, so I'm glad you enjoyed it. Politics does have a way of taking a hand in police work, doesn't it?

    1. Yes, that facet certainly added to the story. I do like it when external pressures add to the burden of the investigator! There's an old song......A policeman's lot is not a happy one!

  2. Ok, sounds good enough, glad you liked it, but probably not sticking put as a choice for me when there's so much else around.

    1. I did enjoy it and it was another Scottish book ticked off for me.

  3. I've heard of this series -- a favorable review somewhere -- and have it on my hit list. Thanks for the reminder!

  4. Col, there is a sense of realism when a detective is caught between his personal obligations and professional duties. I like that personal element in detection-mystery fiction. I mean, you can't be sleuthing all the time, can you?

    1. You're right. It's tricky getting that blend right though and I think the author manages it well this time.

  5. I have the first two in this series (unread, of course). The fact that you liked this one is a motivating factor to get closer to reading those.

    1. Haha...unread books? How does that happen? I hope you like them when you get to them. I would enjoy more from him, but have decided against back-tracking on the earlier ones. They would only gather dust.